According to studies, Kalamazoo is in the top 15 best places to live in the U.S. and is the country's least expensive urban area. Now, if these mindblowing statistics interest you, wait until you learn of the best pizza places in the city.
Did you know that over 3 billion pizzas are sold annually in the U.S. alone? Besides that, about 41% of Americans eat pizza weekly. So, are you wondering where to find the best pizza in Kalamazoo?
As a city destined to draw many Americans to live in or visit, Kalamazoo has not been left behind in the pizza industry. The city has more than 60 pizza joints, a staggering statistic for a city of 73,257 inhabitants (2021). But the more pizza joints you find, the harder it will be for you to decide where to eat.
So, we have done the best surveillance for you to come up with the 13 best pizza places in Kalamazoo, Michigan. We looked into different factors to settle on the best: pizza options, dine-in or delivery experience, location, prices, and good customer care.
Ready? Here are the pizza joints in Kalamazoo.
1. Erbelli's Gourmet Pizzeria, Italian Bistro & Pub
Price: $5.50-$27.24 (Menu)
Address: 6214 Stadium Dr, Kalamazoo, MI 49009, United States
Phone: +1 269-375-0408
Erbelli's opened in 1996 and has two locations, with the main one in Kalamazoo. It is one of the best pizza and food joints in Kalamazoo and serves as a full-service pub and Italian bistro. But if pizza is the only thing you want to try out here, you will surely have the best time.
The joint is popular for great pizzas with fancy names, such as N.E.O. (New Erb Order), The Disco Q, The Smooth Ace, P.O.M (Pizza of The Month), and more. Besides the names, these are the best gourmet pizzas cooked with freshly made pizza dough and topped with the best cheese blends, meats, and vegan toppings. They even sell the most delicious gluten-free pizzas.
If you are looking for the best varieties, Erbelli's has you sorted with hand-tossed, pan-style, Detroit-style, or Chicago-style pizzas. They are open from 11:00 am to 8:30 pm daily, and their dining room is also open daily until 7:30 pm. In addition, their reliable delivery service is available daily until 8:00 pm or 9:00 pm on weekends.
2. Bimbo’s Pizza
Price: $5.05- $20.50 (Menu)
Address: 338 Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo, MI 49007
Phone: +1 269-349-3134
Bimbo's Pizza was founded in 1959 and has served the best pizza crusts and toppings for over 60 years. The joint is located in downtown Kalamazoo and offers all types of pizzas, including small, average, to large pizzas, gluten-free pizzas, vegetarian specials, plus more special pizza recipes.
Bimbo's Pizza is popular for its yummy thin, and crispy crust. At the same time, you can customize your favorite toppings from a wide selection, including cheese, pepperoni, meats, ham, olives, green pepper, jalapenos, and more. Besides their friendly and neat service, the best thing about this place has to be how the pizzas are made.
When you order, you can sit back and watch the masters in action since the pizza will be made right before you. They are open from 11:00 am – 08:00 pm on Tuesdays to Fridays and 02:00 pm – 08:00 pm on weekends.
3. Bilbo’s Pizza
Price: $11.15- $33.70 (Menu)
Address: 3307 Stadium Dr, Kalamazoo, MI 49008
Phone: +1 269-382-5544
Bilbo's pizza is another great joint to get a yummy pizza from. The place was founded in 1976 and has maintained a superb reputation for serving delicious pizza. It is also a great place to stop by for delicious food and drinks, thanks to the classy dining arrangement that creates a great environment.
They offer all types of pizzas, including meat, vegetarian, and gluten-free options. You can get screen-baked and pan-style pizza crusts made with freshly-made dough, sauce, and hand-grated cheese. The pizzeria also offers the best nutty whole wheat crusts while also allowing you to make personal pizzas through their website.
They are open for dine-in services daily from not to 9:00 pm from Sunday to Thursday and 10:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays.
4. Bruno’s Pizza
Price: $10.88- $27.90 (Menu)
Address: 1528 W Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo, MI 49006, United States
Phone: +1 269-349-3229
Bruno's Pizza is one of the best restaurants in Kalamazoo, where you can get appetizers, drinks, food for your little ones, and, more importantly, delicious pizzas. The owners, Juanita and her Son, Eugene Erdos, make the place all the more welcoming and interesting, and if your little one is in tow, Eugene will gladly show them how to make hand-tossed pizzas.
They offer different pizza crusts, including thin and thick, hand-tossed options. You also get to choose how many toppings you want for your crust, and you get choices such as extra cheese, pepperoni, bacon, veggies, and B.B.Q. Chicken, and more. They offer pizzas in two sizes, small 12-inch pizza or a large 14-inch crust.
In addition, this is the best restaurant for specialty gourmet pizza, with dine-in or take-out options available. They are open from 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm, but it's a bit of a bummer that they don't sell alcohol or make pizza delivery.
5. Jet’s Pizza
Price: $7.99 to $33.00 (Menu)
Address: 3321 Stadium Dr. Kalamazoo, MI 49008
Phone: +1 269-372-2600
This beautiful restaurant was established in 1978 by Eugene Jetts. Interestingly, he leased the first restaurant location on his way to buy a home. The rest remains history because 40 years later, Jet's Pizza is one of the best places to order a filling Detroiter pizza or even a specialty B.B.Q. Chicken pizza.
Enjoy home delivery or take-out, and you are guaranteed your Detroit-style pizza is made with fresh ingredients, including freshly made pizza dough, fresh mozzarella that is hand-grated, fresh meats, and fresh veggies. In addition, you are left with choices to make for your best crust, starting from a Detroit-style Deep Dish 8-corner pizza, a thin-crust New York Style pizza, or a gluten-free crust.
They are open weekdays from 10:30 am - 10:00 pm and up to 11:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays.
6. Louie’s Trophy House
Price: From $14.00 (Menu)
Address: 629 Walbridge St Kalamazoo, MI 49007
Phone: +1 269-385-9359
Louie's Trophy House was established in 1918 and is a spot rich in American and Michigan history. It started as a soup kitchen serving paper industry workers and has continued to thrive so well since it is one of the best pizza restaurants in Kalamazoo.
The joint offers different types of pizza, including the small, Garbage pie, the B.B.Q. Chicken pizza, and Frankie Valli Italiano Pizza, all served with Louie's homemade bbq sauce. Additionally, all Louie's Trophy House pizzas have a homemade crust you will find nowhere else, and they only use whole milk mozzarella cheese and other fresh toppings.
This pizza place is also famous for delicious appetizers, burgers, salads, sandwiches, and wraps. In addition, they offer dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup options from 11:00 am - 12:00 am (next day) on Mondays to Wednesdays, 7:00 am - 12:00 am (next day)on Thursdays and Fridays, 11:00 am - 2:00 am on Saturday, and 11:00 am - 11:00 pm on Sunday.
7. Jaspare’s Pizza
Price: From $7.35 (Menu)
Address: 5965 S Sprinkle Rd Portage, MI 49002
Phone: +1 269-388-4810
If you are a fan of Italian food, Jaspare's Pizza is a restaurant you don't want to miss. The pizza place was founded in 1977 by Jaspare Matranga, who later sold it to his cousins, who added the Italian food menu that made the joint successful. Today, this pizza restaurant is known for delicious gourmet pizza.
They make the yummiest hand-tossed, gluten-free, and square-pan pizza crusts that they then layer with classic cheese plus other toppings, including meats, veggies, mushrooms, and more delicacies.
The restaurant opens from 11:00 am - 10:00 pm. They take reservations and offer take-out and delivery.
8. Sarkozy Bakery
Price: From $6.00 (Menu)
Address: 350 E Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo, MI 49007, United States
Phone: +1 269-342-1952
The Sarkozy Bakery is the best in the whole of Michigan. The bakery was established in 1978 and is popular for baking the best delicacies, including pastries, bread, and cookies. They also make pizzas, and you can trust their dough preparation to surpass any average pizza you may come across in your journey.
The bakery offers a yummy pizza dubbed Y.V.O. (Your Very own). It is offered in 8" and 10" sizes with two toppings of choice. If you want to experiment with more toppings, you will pay an extra $0.50 for each. They open 7:30 am – 5:00 pm from Mon-Fri and close at 4:00 pm on Saturday, and you can take away or dine in.
9. Roma’s Pizza
Price: From $3.05 (Menu)
Address: 1401 S Drake Rd Kalamazoo, MI 49006
Phone: +1 269-372-7662
Roma's is another excellent restaurant to order from if you crave good Italian food. They make some of the yummiest pizzas in the city thanks to their exer-fresh handmade dough and fresh, low-moisture, low-skim mozzarella cheese.
Some of their best pizza offers include their in-house pizza made with a special recipe, including mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, pepperoni, and ham. Others are the Silician-style pizza, B.B.Q. Chicken pizza, Hawaiian pizza, and vegetarian options. Remember to try out their delicious appetizers, salads, and sauces.
The pizza place opens from 11:00 am every day.
10. Buddy’s Pizza
Price: From $13.49 (Menu)
Address: 5314 S Westnedge Ave Portage, MI 49002
Phone: +1 269-3421-9233
If you are a fan of Detroit-style pizza, you will be glad to know it originated in this beautiful restaurant. Once upon a time, in 1946, when Gus Guerra and Concetta "Connie" Piccinato made the first-ever square pizza baked on forged-steel pans. Since then, this pizza style has become a favorite for many pizza lovers.
So, you will definitely want to try this award-winning pizza in this restaurant, although you can also enjoy other delicacies like salads, sandwiches, pasta, and drinks.
The pizza place opens at 11:00 am daily. You can also dine in, take out, or order pizza from home.
11. Pizza Katerina
Price: $16.97 to $31.89 (Menu)
Address: 635 N 9th St Ste E Kalamazoo, MI 49009
Phone: +1 269-216-3651
There is something special about a New York-style pizza, and if you have tried other pizzas, you will know how natural this one feels because you can fold it and eat it on the move. If you are in Michigan wondering where to enjoy such a pizza, look no further than the Pizza Katerina restaurant.
Their main offer is the 14" New York-style pizza characterized by a thin, soft, and well-cooked wheat crust. Their pizza is unique, not for being offered in Kalamazoo, but because theirs is a homemade recipe that starts with fresh ingredients like dough, cheese, and toppings.
If wheat is not your friend, pop in for the best gluten-free pizza in the city, and you'll find them ready from 11:00 am on Thursday to Saturday, from noon every Sunday, and 3:00 pm and 4:30 pm on Monday and Tuesday, and Wednesday, respectively.
12. Chicago Style Pizza
Price: $7.00 to $17.75 (Menu)
Address: 10420 Portage Rd Portage, MI 49002
Phone: +1 269-323-0807
While named after one of the tastiest pizza styles, this Portage-based joint has been operational since 1979. You can enjoy the best deep-dish pan, thin crust, or stuffed pizza here. In addition to pizzas, you are in for tasty baked subs, drinks, and a good dining experience.
They open from 10:00 am Tuesdays to Fridays and noon every Sunday. They also offer reliable delivery services if you are close to the restaurant.
13. Neds On Gull Lake
Price: From $9.99 (Menu)
Address: 15450 M-43 Hwy Hickory Corners, MI 49060
Phone: +1 269-671-5700
Ned on Gull Lake is a full-service bar that also offers specialty pizzas. The joint was established in 2008 by Jeff B., who owns and operates Boogie Barbeque and Catering.
If you are not here for their best liquor and micro-beer collection, you need to try their pizzas. You have various choices, but their pizzas have a thin crust topped with fresh veggies, meats, mozzarella, and other cheeses. In addition, you can also try their 10-inch pizza gluten-free pizza.
The restaurant opens 11:00 am - 9:30 pm and later, but you have to get your pizza yourself as they don't deliver. Fortunately, there are ample outside seating options with Wi-Fi, making it an ideal spot for lunches, dinners, and late-night eat-outs.
Takeaway
Hopefully, you found a convenient restaurant to get your pizza from in Kalamazoo. These are the best pizza places in the city, so you can expect the best service whether dining in, getting take-out, or ordering from home. So, the ball is in your court; which pizza place in K'zoo is most convenient for you?
