The 11 Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL [2023]

Are you looking for a restaurant that serves the best pizza in Gainesville? Worry no more! This article provides you with the 10 best pizza places in Gainsville, FL, that you should try.

Let's get started!

1. Gumby’s Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 2028 SW 34th St, Gainesville, FL 32608, United States

Phone: +13523748629

Rates: 4.0(829 reviews)

Gumby's Pizza is a casual franchise restaurant that offers a variety of foods on its menu, including; pizza, wings, and Italian comfort food. With outlets all around, Gumby's Pizza is demonstrating that it is more than simply a pizza chain; it is also a mark of high caliber.

For takeout or delivery, they provide tasty pizza, hot sub sandwiches, Pepperoni Rolls, salads, Pokey Stix, and buffalo wings. The pizza place prepares its dough daily and only uses the best recent meats and veggies. In addition, Gumby makes its fine pizza sauces by combining tomatoes with various spices and simmering them. So, visit Gumby's Pizza today to satisfy your appetite.

Gumby's Pizza will accept your order and have it ready in minutes. Their internal attitude is "don't simply satisfy the consumers - amaze them!" They live up to this in every delivery.

Specialty: Mushroom Pizza recipe with ham, sausage, pineapple, Teriyaki sauce, meatballs, spinach, green peppers, black olives, bbq chicken, pepperoni, ranch, onions, bacon, banana pepper, jalapenos, ground beef, mushrooms, garlic, tomatoes, BBQ sauce, and honey mustard. We recommend you try their "pokey stix" combo, a combination of garlic cheese bread served with pizza.

2. Satchel’s Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 1800 NE 23rd Ave, Gainesville, FL 32609, United States

Phone: +13523357272

Rates: 4.7(3,047 reviews)

Satchel's is always mentioned when people in Gainesville are asked about a must-try local eatery. Satchel's Pizza opened in 2003 and is well-known for its unique aesthetic, exciting events, and delectable pizza. Various vibrant, artistic statues welcome you when you first enter Satchels. The walls are decorated with stained glass windows, and a blue "hippy van" is parked in the courtyard.

Satchel's Pizza provides all the essential ingredients for a top-notch pizzeria. Speed and a wide selection of filled pies. It's all about the pizza, as it says on the menu. While they provide a traditional cheese pie, they are more renowned for the variety of toppings you may use to create a custom dish.

With the almost limitless topping options, Satchel's is proud of its deep-dish pizza, where you can order three toppings and extra cheese for $7. This restaurant's atmosphere is fantastic, besides the delicious cuisine. You'll see that it's not your typical location, about which they logically make fun. Instead, it makes it the ideal location to visit with children.

Almost every day, Satchel's has live entertainment that you may enjoy while you dine, including trivia, live music, and story-telling for small children. You may even have dinner in another restaurant section if that's not your thing. Since Satchel's is popular and open from Tuesday through Saturday, there may be some congestion. Please make reservations on their website and treat your taste buds to great food.

3. Leonardo’s Pizza Of Millhopper

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 4131 NW 16th Blvd, Gainesville, FL 32605, United States

Phone: +13523762001

Rates: 4.6(668 reviews)

Leonardo's is a well-known brand of a pizza restaurant in Gainesville. Gainesville's Leonardo's Pizza of Millhopper was established next to Devil's Millhopper, and a few years later, in 1979, Tina and Gregg Brannan acquired it.

Even looking at the menu will make your mouth wet for their Chicago-style Pizza. It will take longer to decide what is best than for the order to be served. The sides of Leonardo's Pizza of Millhopper are prepared in the same manner as their primary dish. Hand-tied garlic knots will be the finest ever company for your pizza.

Order the Big Leo, an all-time favorite pizza shop that never gets tired of perfect, if you need one of the greatest pizzas in the neighborhood.

A traditional favorite, the Big Leo Pizza includes sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and pepperoni. Pizza by the pan is the restaurant's primary menu item, although it also serves other dishes, including manicotti, lasagna, garlic rolls, chicken parmesan, and more. In addition, every day of the week, a dinner special with garlic bread and access to the salad bar is available, along with a varied choice of pizza by the slice.

4. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 5200 NW 43rd St, Gainesville, FL 32608, United States

Phone: +13523717437

Rates: 4.6(918 reviews)

Local chain Piesanos operates three locations in the Gainesville vicinity and specializes in offering stone-fired pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and other dishes. Additionally, it sells rolls known as Piesanos, topped with Parmesan cheese and served with Italian dressing.

Everyone is catered to on their menu, and they even provide gluten-free items and vegan pizza cheese recipes upon request. Like most other pizzerias, Piesanos enables you to build your own pizza with a range of traditional and unique toppings like artichoke hearts or eggplant.

At Piesanos, we advise staying with their pre-made gourmet specialty pizzas. There are 29 specialty pizzas, like the Palmero Special with calabrese peppers, sausage, onions, and garlic and the Pepperoni Explosion pizza with pepperoni and double cheese.

Additionally, a full bar with various happy hour offers is available. Of course, trying the pizzas is necessary, but the meatballs and Philly cheese steak are also quite popular. Paisanos Pizza spot serves large quantities and makes great handmade bread.

We recommend you resist the free house rolls no matter how tempting they may be, as you won't have room for this enormous pizza if you eat too many of them.

5. Blaze Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 3617 SW Archer Rd, Gainesville, FL 32608, United States

Phone: +13524585208

Rates: 4.7(2,947 reviews)

Blaze Pizza is a well-known establishment with locations across the US and Canada. But, like restaurants like Chipotle or Subway, Blaze Pizza is unique because you pay a set price for your pizza and may top it with any number of your preferred toppings.

You won't ever have to wait too long, despite the lengthy lines, as the pizza is baked to perfection in under two minutes. The unique aspect of this Pizza restaurant is the Chipotle-style ordering, which allows customers to customize their pie by choosing the toppings and quantity they like as the crew prepares it.

Blaze Pizza serves crispy, thick-crust pizzas with creative toppings and sauces. Each pizza made at this restaurant has an unmatched style and flavor. Every day, they make fresh vegetables and salads served either indoors or as entrees. Among their delectable offerings are arugula pizza, Tomato, Classic Caesar, Fresh Fruit, and Mozzarella pizzas.

The eatery serves cheese pizza, meat, and vegetables. Additionally, you may place an online order and have it delivered straight to your door. They also provide seasonal specials as a bonus feature. You must give them a try if you enjoy pizza! Additionally, they offer a Blaze Rewards program where you may sign up and receive free food, desserts, and drinks.

6. Humble Wood Fire

Price: $$(menu)

Address: 619 S Main St Unit 1B, Gainesville, FL 32601, United States

Phone: +13523392716

Rates: 5.0(6 reviews)

Humble Pie is a little less traditional than the other businesses described above, as it is the only joint that serves meals on a food truck. Humble Pie frequently sets up at food truck rallies and events around Gainesville. You can also hire them to cater an event privately. To keep track of their locations, visit their website to view the event schedule.

The pizza is a 10-inch pie with a thin crust created in the Neapolitan style, and it is cooked at 1000 degrees in their custom-built, wood pizza oven. Pies from Humble Pie are extremely fresh and of the highest caliber since they primarily use seasonal, local, and organic ingredients. They also make their bagels, a lovely way to start the day. So you can have the nicest breakfast with a starter bread and a delicious pizza.

The Sweet/Savory, the Clifton, which has kale pesto, walnuts, mozzarella, and blue cheese, and the Bianca, which has herb-infused olive oil, ricotta, arugula, garlic, mozzarella, and parmesan, are some of the fan favorites.

We recommend you try the Humble breakfast pie, routinely served on the last week at the Union Street Farmers' Market, topped with eggs from nearby hens.

7. Amelia’s Italian Restaurant

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: Behind the Hippodrome, 235 S Main St, Suite 107, Gainesville, FL 32601, United States

Phone: +13523731919

Rates: 4.6(444 reviews)

According to Amelia's guarantee, every visitor will notice the difference from the first mouthful. It is because every order of traditional Italian pizza is prepared from scratch.

Amelia elevates pizza with top-notch toppings and fresh ingredients under Natural Cooking. Their website even provides videos showing you how to prepare and enjoy nutritious homemade meals.

The pizza joint is open from Tuesday to Sunday for ordering and pick-up. If you want to eat there, you must make reservations.

8. Five-Star Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 600 NW 75th St, Gainesville, FL 32607, United States

Phone: +13523337979

Rates: 4.3(414 reviews)

Five Star Pizza is a fast food restaurant company that is locally owned and operated that started in the Gainesville region. Customers may order huge servings of pizza, chicken wings, pepperoni rolls, buffalo chicken, and other items for carryout or delivery. The food joint offers promotions from Five Star Pizza to lower the price of your meal even further. The meal is inexpensive and served quickly.

If you want to visit Gainesville in the Durant Estates, Pleasant Street, or Northwood communities, locate a house close to a Five Star Pizza. Whatever kind of pizza you're searching for, you can probably find it in the Gainesville region because there are so many different locations to eat from.

9. Scuola Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 5240 NW 34th Blvd, Gainesville, FL 32605, United States

Phone: +13524514122

Rates: 4.6(321 reviews)

We found Scuola Pizza great as its mission aims to reinvent the eating experience. Moreover, the pizza joint is concerned with the environment and food.

This pizza, which has Greek roots, introduces Mediterranean cuisine to Gainsville, Florida. Eat a unique, freshly prepared pizza and read some fascinating books.

The 11 Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL [2023]

Image Credits:

Their menu allows you to choose from a range of meat and veggie toppings to create your own pizza or try the customized pita pizza with up to two toppings.

It's also smart to let Scuola Pizza select what you eat. We assure you that it will be enjoyable to try many Greek combinations of pre-designed pies, including their Gyro pizza.

10. Peppino’s Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 3731 W University Ave, Gainesville, FL 32607, United States

Phone: +13525546078

Rates: 4.7(185 reviews)

Peppino's Pizza conveys the sentiment that any family-run eatery ought to have; a welcoming atmosphere and a home-cooked dinner.

Peppino's offers a vast range of toppings and ingredients to make your pizza experience delightful.

You should try one of their calzones to see if you can eat it all. This establishment stands out because of its great, delicious pieces of filled bread.

Image Credits: SAE Miller,

If you're in the area, don't hesitate to stop by Peppino's because it's open from Tuesday through Saturday.

11. Pleasant Street Pizza

Price: $$(Menu)

Address: 308 NW 5th Ave, Gainesville, FL 32601, United States

Phone: +13527926773

Rates: 5.0(8 reviews)

The scores given to Pleasant Street Pizza online are accurate; thus, they deserve their ranking. In addition, the Pizza restaurant pays a lot of attention when crafting its pizzas.

The food joint serves one of the best pizza pie recipes in Gainesville, Florida, made with natural sourdough bread, fresh vegetable toppings, and a moderate quantity of cheese. This Pizza restaurant will disprove your notion that wholesome food can't be delicious.

We recommend you take advantage of their freshly introduced "Verdura Pizza," which has braised collards, almonds, shaved parmesan cheese, thin red onion, and olive oil. The restaurant is unmissable on Pleasant Street.

Featured Image Credits:

The 11 Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL [2023]